Analysis: Housing slowdown takes hold of Canada

Buyers taking control, sellers scared; tight mortgage rules limit risk of  U.S.-style meltdown

TORONTO – Long convinced the country’s housing boom would never end in a  crash, Canadians have watched this autumn as a sharp slowdown in real estate  spreads across the country, leaving would-be home buyers hopeful and sellers  scared.

“The power is in the hands of the buyer — that’s what I’m feeling,” said  Andria Petrillo, 32, as she and her husband toured a quiet open house in the  heart of Toronto, where crowds and chaos once reigned over weekend home  showings.

But like most people shopping for a new home, Petrillo has to sell her old  one first. And that’s where she worries.

“With the economy, I’d like to sell now. I worry about selling because it’s a  condo, and that market is cooling even faster than houses,” said the newly  married sportscaster. “We can’t sell it for a ridiculous amount of money any  more.”

Signs are everywhere that Canada’s long run-up in house prices is over, hit  by a combination of tighter mortgage lending rules and growing consumer  reluctance to take on more debt. Sales of existing homes are down steeply, with  condo sales hit especially hard, and some long-booming prices have started to  fall.

Sales always slump as the real estate market heads into winter. The big  question will be whether spring brings renewal, or confirmation that the party  is over.


Canadian households hold more debt than American families did before the U.S.  housing bubble burst, which has led the government to tighten mortgage lending  rules four times in four years.

And data released on Wednesday showed the Canadian economy shrank in August,  an unexpected downturn that bodes ill for housing even as the U.S. economy shows  signs of recovering.

The debate in Canada is whether the market will come down with a thud or make  a relatively soft landing, as most mainstream economists predict. They see a 10  to 15 per cent correction in prices and a slowing in housing starts to 180,000 a  year by 2014, down sharply from the 220,000 range today. In that scenario, GDP  growth would be cut by 1 to 1.5 percentage points, according to CIBC World  Markets.

The Bank of Canada has forecast economic growth of just 2.3 per cent in 2013  and 2.4 per cent in 2014.

“In a final analysis, not all is well in the Canadian housing market,” CIBC  economist Benjamin Tal wrote in a report this week, pointing to prices that have  overshot fundamentals in large cities like Toronto and Vancouver.

Tal believes slower sales activity will be followed by falling prices in many  cities. But he says Canadian lending standards have been higher, and borrowers  more cautious, than in the United States before its crash, which will prevent  large-scale mortgage defaults and plunging prices.

Mindful of what happened in the United States, the Canadian government has  tightened mortgage rules to prevent home buyers from taking on too much debt.  While interest rates are low and expected to stay low into 2013, the fear is  that eventual rate hikes will drive borrowers out of their homes or into  bankruptcy.

Canada’s Big Five banks, which sell and hold the bulk of the nation’s  mortgages, are adjusting to the slowing mortgage market with a stress on other  financial assets, such as credit cards and auto financing, to bolster their  lending businesses as the profitable mortgage market shrinks.

The last round of mortgage rule changes took effect in July, forcing home  buyers to cut back on their budget and pushing many prospective first-time  buyers out of the market entirely.

Economists and real estate agents alike applauded the move.

“It’s had a definite impact on first-time buyers. Money is almost free, but  you shouldn’t give them too much rope,” said Ron Carroll, a real estate agent in  Toronto.

Home sales have slowed dramatically in the months since the rule change took  effect, and prices are expected to follow.

Sales of existing homes were down 15.1 per cent in September from a year  earlier, and were 6.5 per cent lower in the third quarter from the previous  three months, according to data from the Canadian Real Estate Association.

Prices, which typically lag sales, have started to come down as well. Overall  prices dipped 0.4 per cent in September from August, according the  Teranet-National Bank Composite House Price Index released last week. While  prices are still up 3.6 per cent from a year earlier, it was the 10th straight  month of decelerating price gains.

As the Canadian real estate market heads into winter, sales are expected to  slump, as usual, with hibernation beginning in late November.


While the national housing market appears to be retreating in an orderly way,  the data show pockets of sharper slowdown, particularly in the western Canadian  cities of Vancouver and Victoria, which once led the hot housing market.

“Personally I don’t see any revitalization of the market in the near future,” said Victoria real estate agent Tony Joe, noting that investors have left the  market.

Residential sales fell 8.3 per cent in September from a year earlier in  Victoria and were down 32.5 per cent in Vancouver, according to the local real  estate boards. Prices were down 2.6 per cent in Victoria and 1.4 per cent in  Vancouver on the year, according to the Teranet report.

The price declines are far smaller than the plunge that hit U.S. homeowners  during the crash. Still, buyers are hesitant, wondering if they should wait  until next year to purchase.

“Sellers will commonly say, ‘I’m going to wait until the spring, when the  market is better.’ And I warn them that it could be worse,” said Joe. “And of  course buyers are saying ‘It looks like things are bad, I’m going to hold off  until the market drops another 10 or 20 per cent.”’

Joe, a 21-year industry veteran, does not foresee such a drastic decline,  simply because Canadian lenders have been prudent and interest rates are not  going up soon. Sellers will pull houses off the market rather than accept a  price drop.

But buyers appear ready to wait as well, even in markets such as Toronto,  where prices are not yet falling.

“We have all the time in the world, and we’re waiting to find some value,” said Sandra Blake, a lawyer who moved back to Toronto from Geneva with her  husband two years ago and has been waiting for a more sensible market to  buy.

Blake spends every weekend touring open houses in Toronto’s good  neighbourhoods, and sees the market starting to slow. Her brother just sold his  house in the city’s west end, afraid the market would collapse before he could  move into a new house.

“He was afraid of waiting,” said Blake.

© Copyright (c) The Montreal Gazette

Read more:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s